Institutional structures of economic
      promotion
      
Economic promotion activities can be organized in different
      institutional forms.
      In many industrialized countries, as well as in some advanced
      developing countries, regional and local economic promotion is organized
      as a separate public service entity. This may be a department of
      local government or an organizationally separate entity.
      Another option is to organize economic promotion as a public-private
      partnership, where it depends on the specific circumstances which side has
      the majority stake.
      Yet another option is an active role of Chambers and Associations
      or utilities in local economic promotion. In particular in the U.S.
      it is quite common to find that utilities play this role, which is
      motivated by the interest to attract new large-scale customers for their
      services.
      The following table summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of each
      type. It should become obvious that there is no clear first-best option.
      
        
          | 
             Type  | 
          
             Advantage  | 
          
             Disadvantage  | 
        
        
          | 
             Public  | 
          
            
              - Direct contact to public administration
 
              - Potential strategic role, beyond short-term thinking
              
  
           | 
          
            
              - Distance to private sector
 
              - Risk of bureaucratic culture
 
              - Risk of political peddling
              
  
           | 
        
        
          | 
             Public-private  | 
          
            
              - Flexibility
 
              - Potentially business-like organizational culture
            
  
           | 
          
            
              - Lack of democratic accountability
 
              - Different, potentially conflictive expectations of public and
                private stakeholders
 
              - Distant from economically relevant departments of public
                administration
            
  
           | 
        
        
          | 
             Chambers and Associations  | 
          
            
              - Very close to the private sector
 
              - Business-orientation
            
  
           | 
          
            
              - Distance to the public sector
 
              - Conflict between lobbying and promotion
            
  
           | 
        
        
          | 
             Utilities  | 
          
            
              - Business-orientation
 
              - Clear performance indicators
            
  
           | 
          
            
              - Distance to the public sector
            
  
           | 
        
      
         
        
back
        to: business-friendly orientation of government
      
        
top